In Silico Assessment of Preclinical Disease Models

industrial-doctorate
bioinformatics
rare-diseases
Industrial doctorate developing computational methods to quantify how faithfully animal models reproduce human disease — enabling principled model selection before drug testing begins. In collaboration with Almirall SA.
Keywords

industrial doctorate, preclinical models, single-cell RNA-seq, singIST, atopic dermatitis, skin disease, Almirall, computational biology, drug development, UPC

Type Industrial Doctorate (Doctorat Industrial)
Doctoral student Aitor Moruno-Cuenca
Supervisor Alexandre Perera Lluna
Company partner Almirall SA (formerly Laboratoris Almirall SA)
University Universitat Politècnica de Catalunya (UPC)
Reference futur.upc.edu/37915145
Status Active

Context: A long-standing problem in drug development

One of the most persistent frustrations in biomedical research is a simple, costly mismatch: a treatment that works in mice often fails in humans. A major reason is that the animal models used to test drug candidates are selected largely based on qualitative judgement — shared symptoms, broad gene expression overlap, or historical convention — rather than rigorous, quantitative comparison to the human disease.

The consequence is systematic: if the model does not capture the biology that the drug targets, the experiment tells you nothing useful, regardless of how well the drug performs. This is a major driver of high attrition rates in clinical trials, particularly in complex inflammatory and immune-mediated diseases.

Almirall SA is a Barcelona-headquartered pharmaceutical company specialising in dermatology and immunology-mediated skin diseases. Their pipeline includes treatments for psoriasis, atopic dermatitis, hidradenitis suppurativa, and other conditions where preclinical modelling is both essential and notoriously difficult. The need for better, more principled methods to evaluate animal models before committing to costly development programmes is a direct industrial challenge that this doctorate addresses.


Research: singIST — a quantitative framework for model comparison

The central contribution of this industrial doctorate is singIST (single-cell Integrative Similarity Tool), a computational method that quantifies how faithfully a preclinical disease model reproduces the biology of the corresponding human disease — at the resolution of individual cell types, biological pathways, and genes.

singIST workflow diagram showing the three nested comparison levels: pathway, cell type, and gene

singIST workflow: from single-cell transcriptomic data in model and human to pathway-level similarity scores across cell types.

How singIST works

singIST takes single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) data from both a preclinical model (typically mouse) and human patients and computes similarity at three nested levels:

Note

Three levels of comparison

Pathway level
Are the same biological processes disrupted in the model as in the human disease? A high pathway-level score means the model recapitulates the relevant biology at a mechanistic level.
Cell type level
Are the same cell populations involved? This matters because a drug targeting keratinocytes in human disease is irrelevant if that cell type is absent or behaves differently in the model.
Gene level
Are the same individual genes differentially expressed? This is the highest-resolution comparison and is the most sensitive to model-specific artefacts.

The method addresses two biological realities that simpler approaches ignore:

  • Gene conservation: not every human gene has a functional mouse equivalent; singIST accounts for this explicitly rather than silently mapping non-conserved genes.
  • Cell type composition: the relative abundance of cell populations differs between species; a cell type that is common in human disease may be rare or absent in the mouse model.

The result is a set of interpretable similarity scores that allow statements like: “this model captures keratinocyte biology well but misses the dendritic cell response entirely” — rather than just a broad verdict of “similar” or “different”.

Validation on skin disease models

singIST was validated on three mouse models of atopic dermatitis (AD) — a common inflammatory skin condition — and applied to data from human hidradenitis suppurativa (HS), a chronic inflammatory skin disease. These conditions sit squarely within Almirall’s therapeutic focus.

The method reproduced established knowledge (correctly identifying which mouse model best captures the Th2-skewed immune response characteristic of human AD) while generating novel hypotheses about specific pathways and cell types that each model captures or misses. The discriminative power — the ability to distinguish between models that seem superficially similar — is one of the tool’s key practical strengths.


Why this matters for industrial drug development

Tip

The practical value of singIST

Before this work, choosing between mouse model A and mouse model B for a preclinical programme was largely a matter of expertise and precedent. singIST makes that choice systematic, reproducible, and transparent:

  • Run the comparison up front, before any in vivo experiments
  • Get a quantified answer at pathway and cell-type resolution
  • Identify which biological aspects of the human disease the chosen model captures — and which it will miss
  • Reduce the risk of discovering post-hoc (after expensive experiments) that the model was inappropriate

For a company like Almirall, where the therapeutic target is consistently immunology-mediated skin disease, having a principled method to audit candidate models is a direct contribution to reducing development risk and improving the translatability of preclinical results.

The tool is freely available and integrates with standard scRNA-seq pipelines — no additional data collection is required beyond what a well-equipped computational biology team already produces.


Publication

Note

singIST: An integrative method for comparative single-cell transcriptomics between disease models and humans

Moruno-Cuenca A, Picart-Armada S, Bogle R, Fox J, Tsoi LC, Gudjonsson JE, Perera-Lluna A, Fernández-Albert F. PLOS Computational Biology, 2026. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pcbi.1014002

Developed in collaboration with the University of Michigan (Tsoi, Gudjonsson groups), leaders in the genetics and single-cell biology of skin inflammatory disease.

Related blog post: Does your mouse model actually look like a human disease? Now there’s a tool to check, cell by cell


About the partners

Almirall SA is a Barcelona-based, publicly listed pharmaceutical company founded in 1943. Its R&D is focused on dermatology and immunology-mediated skin diseases, with marketed products including treatments for psoriasis, atopic dermatitis, and actinic keratosis. The company has a strong tradition of academic collaboration in Catalonia and internationally.

B2SLab / IRIS-UPC contributes computational biology, machine learning, and bioinformatics expertise. The collaboration exemplifies the Catalan Industrial Doctorate programme’s goal of linking university research directly to industrial R&D needs.

Industrial Doctorate programme funded by the Generalitat de Catalunya (Secretaria d’Universitats i Recerca).